Bullshit Something Principle

Ever found yourself in a debate, armed with facts, logic, and a perfectly reasoned argument, only to feel like you're trying to nail jelly to a wall? You present a meticulously sourced piece of information, and your opponent counters with a wild, baseless claim that sounds vaguely plausible to the casual listener. You then spend ten times the effort debunking their nonsense than it took them to invent it.

If this sounds like your last family dinner or that endless scroll through social media comments, then congratulations! You've just experienced Brandolini's Law in action.

So, What in the Heck is Brandolini's Law?

Also known as the "Bullshit Asymmetry Principle," Brandolini's Law states:

"The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it."

In plain English: It takes way, WAY more effort to debunk a false claim than it does to make one up.

This isn't some ancient philosophical text or a deep scientific theorem. It was coined in 2013 by Alberto Brandolini, an Italian programmer, who, after a particularly frustrating online debate, summed up this universal truth with exasperated brilliance.



Why Does This Law Ring So True?

Think about it:

  1. Making stuff up is easy: You don't need evidence, research, or logical consistency. Just creativity (or a complete lack of scruples). "The moon landing was faked because the flag was waving!" – Instant, memorable, easily digestible.

  2. Debunking is hard work: To refute that moon landing claim, you need to explain the physics of a flag in a vacuum (it's held up by a rod, appears to ripple due to creases), atmospheric pressure, the complexity of NASA, and why such a conspiracy is practically impossible to keep secret. This takes time, knowledge, and multiple sentences.

See the asymmetry? One sentence of nonsense, five paragraphs of truth. It's an unfair fight!

Real-World Examples Where Brandolini's Law Reigns Supreme:

Example 1: Your Aunt's "Health Facts" on WhatsApp

Auntie's Claim (Bullshit Production): "Did you know that drinking warm lemon water with a pinch of baking soda every morning cures all diseases and makes you immortal? My friend's neighbor's cousin shared it on WhatsApp! Doctors don't want you to know!" Time to produce: 5 seconds to type.

Your Refutation (Effort to Debunk): You'd have to explain the actual pH balance of the human body, the function of kidneys, the lack of scientific studies, and the dangers of getting medical advice from random WhatsApp forwards. Time to refute: 5 minutes of frantic Googling, 10 minutes of typing, 1 hour of arguing with Auntie.

Example 2: The Widely Believed Urban Myth

Myth-Spreader's Claim (Bullshit Production): "If you swallow chewing gum, it stays in your stomach for seven years!" Time to produce: 3 seconds to say.

Your Refutation (Effort to Debunk): You'd need to explain the basics of the digestive system, how the body processes indigestible substances, and that while gum isn't digested, it typically passes through the system in a day or two like other fiber. Time to refute: 1 minute of explaining, 5 minutes of answering follow-up questions about what else can pass through.

The Brandolini's Battle Strategy

So, what's the takeaway? Brandolini's Law isn't just a witty observation; it's a warning.

  1. Choose your battles wisely: Not every piece of nonsense deserves your meticulous refutation. Sometimes, silence (or a well-placed eye-roll) is golden.

  2. Keep it simple: If you must refute, try to make your counter-argument as concise and digestible as the original nonsense. Use analogies. Focus on one or two key facts.

  3. Know your audience: Are you trying to convince the person who made the claim (often futile), or the fence-sitters observing the debate? Tailor your approach.

  4. Don't get frustrated: It's not you failing; it's Brandolini's Law doing its thing. Acknowledge the asymmetry, protect your mental energy, and save your well-researched arguments for people who genuinely want to learn.

In a world drowning in easily produced misinformation, understanding Brandolini's Law is less about winning every argument and more about preserving your sanity. So next time someone drops a steaming pile of "yappanese" on you, take a deep breath, chuckle internally, and remember: it's not you, it's the law.

Thank You for Reading,

Hetansh Shah


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The True Value of Overpricing

Image
 If you’ve ever been to an Indian market, you’ve probably witnessed (or participated in) the age-old ritual of bargaining. Whether it’s haggling with an auto-rickshaw driver over ₹10, negotiating with a street vendor for an extra lemon, or convincing the shopkeeper to round down the price of bangles, we Indians love a good deal. It’s in our DNA—we take pride in securing the best price possible. But sometimes, just sometimes, it’s okay to pay a little extra for something you truly like. That ₹5, ₹10, or even ₹20 extra isn’t just about money; it’s about the value of joy. Because It Feels Right Imagine this: You’re at your favorite chai tapri, the kind that serves tea in earthen kulhads. You can get chai for ₹10 at the next stall, but this stall makes it just right—kadak (strong), with the perfect balance of adrak and elaichi. The shopkeeper tells you it’s ₹15. Do you bargain, or do you simply hand over the extra ₹5 because this is the chai your heart wants ? Sometimes, that extr...
Read more

Following Your Conscience

Image
Imagine being torn between everything you've been taught and everything you've experienced. That’s exactly where Huck Finn finds himself in Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn . Society tells him that helping Jim, a runaway slave, is wrong—sinful, even. Yet, every moment spent with Jim reveals a different truth: kindness, loyalty, and friendship that transcends race and social norms. Picture Huck holding a letter he’s written to Miss Watson, ready to betray Jim. But then he remembers—the laughter they shared, the times Jim protected him, the genuine care in Jim’s eyes. And in that moment, Huck does something extraordinary. He tears up the letter and declares, “All right, then, I’ll go to hell!” This isn’t just a rebellious act; it's Huck’s way of saying, “I trust my heart more than the world around me.” It’s a moment we all can relate to—when we realize that what everyone else believes might not be what we believe. Think about it: How often do we find ourselves ...
Read more