The Dictator's Playbook, Chapter 2: The Guest List
Every office has that one meeting that "could have been an email."
This one could have been a hostage situation.
Baghdad, July 22, 1979. A mandatory all-hands. No agenda was circulated beforehand. (Mostly because the agenda was a list of names, and you don't send that in advance.)
Last chapter, we watched five men climb to the top. This chapter is about what they did next, which is the part of the job description that never makes it into the brochure: getting rid of the people who helped them get there.
Grab a snack. Maybe not one you'll want to eat during Section 1.
The Worst All-Hands in History
Six days after becoming president, Saddam Hussein summoned hundreds of Ba'ath Party leaders to Al-Khuld Hall. The doors were locked. The camera was rolling. Saddam had ordered the whole thing videotaped, because why waste a good production budget on just one night?
Then a senior party figure named Muhyi Abdul-Hussein Mashhadi walked up to the podium and "confessed" to being part of a Syrian-backed plot. And, being a team player, he started naming other people in the room. Sixty-eight names, to be exact. As each name was read, security politely walked that person out. No speeches. No goodbyes. Just a guy in the front row quietly hoping the next name wasn't his. Imagine a roll call where "present" is the wrong answer.
Meanwhile, the people still seated reportedly started chanting "Long live Saddam!" at a volume you can only achieve when the exit is locked. Saddam, according to one account, sat nearby at a small table, puffing a cigar like a man watching his favorite show.
When the list ended, he congratulated everyone left in the room for their loyalty. Applause, one imagines, was enthusiastic and slightly damp. The 68 were tried together. Twenty-two were sentenced to death, and on August 8, Iraqi state media announced that 21 had been shot. Several accounts say party members were handed the guns, which is the only team-building exercise where the trust fall is real. Sources disagree on small details, and nobody has ever proved the plot existed.
Respect, Saddam. Turning an HR meeting into a casting call for your own firing squad is a management style the books never covered.
The Thank-You Card
Now rewind to Stalin. Remember Zinoviev and Kamenev, the two buddies who helped him sideline Trotsky in Chapter 1?
Stalin had a very specific idea of a thank-you card. It was a trial.
It started with a murder. In December 1934, a Communist Party boss named Sergei Kirov was assassinated, and Stalin used it as the excuse that kept on giving. By August 1936, Zinoviev and Kamenev were in a Moscow courtroom. They confessed, were sentenced to death and were executed. In March 1938, the third wheel, Bukharin, got the same treatment. Three allies, three trials, one very thorough pattern.
Then came the numbers. According to Khrushchev's 1956 secret speech, 98 of the 139 Central Committee members and candidates elected in 1934 were later arrested and shot. That's not a reshuffle. That's a hostile takeover of your own board. Across 1937 and 1938, official records count 681,692 executions. Historians argue the real number could be higher.
And Trotsky, the one who escaped? He lasted until 1940, when an NKVD agent found him in Mexico. Even a different continent couldn't beat Stalin's HR department.
Respect, Joseph. Turning "this role is being eliminated" into a literal policy is the scariest corporate restructuring ever.
The Co-Founder Argument
Gaddafi's version of this story is sneakier, because it begins with an argument about money.
Remember the 12 officers who ran Libya after the 1969 coup? One of them was Umar Muhayshi, Gaddafi's childhood friend and later his planning minister. Muhayshi thought Libya's oil money should be spent at home, on farms and factories. Gaddafi wanted it spent on grand causes around the Arab world.
Every startup has that fight. Most of them end with a lawyer.
This one ended with an accusation. In August 1975, Gaddafi said Muhayshi and others were plotting a coup. Muhayshi fled to Tunis and publicly denied it, saying he was only trying to "correct" Gaddafi's mistakes. Most of the other accused were executed in March 1976. By then, a declassified US cable says, every member of the original council except one had turned against Gaddafi. That's a founding team down to a founder and one very loyal deputy.
Muhayshi's story ends darkly. Morocco handed him over in 1983, and by one account he was killed in January 1984. Details of his death rest on a single account, so I'll leave it there.
Respect, Muammar. Losing 11 of 12 co-founders and still insisting you run a "revolution" is peak brand loyalty.
The Great Recruitment Drive
Idi Amin had a problem. He had just taken over an army that belonged to somebody else.
Obote had filled the ranks with soldiers from his own region, mostly Langi and Acholi, which meant Amin was now the CEO of a company full of his predecessor's friends. Any new manager knows that feeling. Amin's solution was to start "mop-up operations," which is a very cheerful name for something that wasn't. By one estimate, about 5,000 Acholi and Lango soldiers were killed by 1972. Another account says about two-thirds of a force of roughly 9,000 soldiers appeared to have been executed in his first year. The numbers are murky, and anyone claiming certainty is guessing.
Then came the hiring spree. Amin recruited from his own West Nile region, then from Sudan and Zaire. It was the first army in history assembled with a hiring policy of "people I already know" and no references. Over eight years, estimates of the total dead run from about 80,000 to 500,000, depending on who is counting.
Respect, Idi. Firing your entire workforce and rehiring your own relatives is the kind of move LinkedIn influencers would call "bold."
The Meeting He Lost (Briefly)
Kim Il Sung's story has the best plot twist, because for about three weeks it looked like he might actually lose.
By 1956, Stalin was dead and Khrushchev was denouncing personality cults across the Communist world. Kim was busy building his own. At a party meeting on August 30, a trade minister named Yun Gong-chin stood up and said the quiet part out loud: that Kim ran a police regime and a cult of personality.
He was shouted down by Kim's supporters. (Kim had done his homework, postponing the meeting, lobbying allies and keeping the police close.) The critics lost their jobs and their party membership. Yun fled across the Yalu River into China, which is the longest commute ever taken to escape a meeting.
Then the grown-ups arrived. A joint delegation from Moscow and Beijing, led by Anastas Mikoyan and Peng Dehuai, turned up in September like parents breaking up a sibling fight. A new meeting on September 23 admitted the punishments were "somewhat hasty," and some critics got their jobs back.
Kim apologized. Kim promised to do better. Kim waited.
By November, he was purging again. One account estimates around 10,000 people were purged over the next couple of years, with roughly 6,000 executed. By 1958, the rival factions were nearly gone. Remember who put him in power in Chapter 1? The Soviets. Now he'd outlasted them too.
Respect, Kim. Losing a fight, waiting for the referees to leave, then winning it anyway is the most patient grudge in history.
The Rule Underneath
Look at who ended up on those lists.
Not strangers. Not enemies. Zinoviev and Kamenev helped Stalin climb. Muhayshi stood next to Gaddafi on day one. Mashhadi sat at the top of Saddam's own party. Kim's critics were his own comrades.
Each of these men needed people to get in the door. Then each of them realized something uncomfortable: the people who helped you in are the ones who know exactly how you did it, and exactly how fragile it was.
Chapter 1 asked how many people held the door open. Chapter 2 is about what happened to them afterward.
Chapter 3 is about the part where nobody had to be dragged out of a room, because the whole country was convinced to clap.
Comments
Post a Comment